Are BCAAs Worth It? A Science-Driven Look
Branch Chain Amino Acids (BCAAs) have become a global phenomenon, with certain companies (no names mentioned, but those familiar with my work will know who I mean) making millions from these supplements. But is that investment truly justified?
My stance is clear: if a supplement genuinely works to enhance human performance, then by all means, it deserves a place in your regimen. However, if the science doesn't back it up, it goes against the values I hold as a sports nutritionist. In this article, we’ll delve deep into BCAAs, exploring their role in amino acid metabolism, their rise to popularity, and most importantly, whether they’re truly worth your money. I'll also provide some evidence-based recommendations on how to optimise your amino acid intake for performance.
What Are BCAAs?
BCAAs consist of three amino acids: Leucine, Isoleucine, and Valine. These are just 3 of the 20 amino acids that serve as the building blocks of protein. Out of these 20, 11 can be synthesized by the body, while the remaining 9 must be obtained through our diet, making them essential amino acids (EAAs). The three BCAAs fall into this essential category, meaning we need to source them from our food. Fortunately, these amino acids are abundant in many protein-rich foods. For instance, Leucine is found in dairy, soy, and legumes, Isoleucine in meat, fish, and nuts, and Valine in soy, cheese, and peanuts.
Given that these amino acids are readily available in a balanced diet, why did BCAAs become so popular as a supplement? There are a couple of reasons. Firstly, BCAAs make up about 20% of the amino acids in muscle, which is significant. Secondly, there was early interest in their potential role in muscle protein synthesis (MPS). These factors caught the attention of the supplement industry, leading to a surge in BCAA products on the market.
Are BCAAs Worth It For Athletes?
Let's examine two common reasons athletes might consider BCAA supplementation. The first is the increased demand for amino acids due to higher protein turnover, especially during endurance exercise where BCAA oxidation increases. However, it's important to remember that for muscle protein synthesis to occur, all 20 amino acids are required. Supplementing with only BCAAs doesn’t address this need. In fact, relying solely on BCAAs would force the body to break down existing muscle protein to obtain the other essential amino acids—a counterproductive approach.
In most cases, the increased demand for amino acids can be met through a balanced diet that includes a variety of protein sources. This makes topping up with BCAAs unnecessary. Now, let's explore the idea that BCAAs can enhance muscle protein synthesis.
The Reality of BCAAs and Muscle Protein Synthesis
If your diet already covers all essential amino acids, will BCAA supplementation further increase muscle protein synthesis? The answer is nuanced. Among the BCAAs, Leucine is known to stimulate the mTOR (mammalian target of rapamycin) signaling pathway, which plays a key role in initiating protein synthesis. So, in theory, increasing Leucine intake could enhance MPS. However, when combined with Isoleucine and Valine, the benefits are diminished. This is because all three BCAAs share the same transporter in the body, leading to less efficient Leucine uptake and, consequently, a reduced effect on muscle protein synthesis.
In practical terms, you would be better off consuming a fast-digesting protein source with a high Leucine content rather than relying on BCAA supplements.
My Recommendations on Branch Chain Amino Acids
Here’s my advice: rather than spending money on BCAA supplements, focus on maintaining a nutrient-dense, high-protein diet that includes a variety of protein sources. If you’re looking for a supplement, opt for one that is rich in Leucine and protein, such as whey protein. For instance, 25 grams of whey protein provides approximately 3 grams of Leucine, making it an excellent choice. For those following a vegan diet, 40 grams of soy protein isolate will deliver a similar Leucine content.
BCAA’s Aren’t Worth It
To optimise your performance, ensure your diet includes adequate amounts of all essential amino acids. There’s no need to invest in BCAAs when a well-rounded diet or a high-quality protein supplement will serve you better. This position is based on the latest research and is aligned with my commitment to evidence-based nutrition strategies.
Need Help Optimising Protein Intake?
I’m a performance nutritionist with 7 years experience and a masters in performance nutrition. See how I can help you achieve your goals here.
